I'd like to raise this issue again as I spent some time last quarter reconciling all of this against the GL. Now I know FA gets the maths right!
This bit on the Wiki makes sense and is how it should be done.
7. So per 01/31/2010 we would enter a JE where we empty the Tax Accounts and counter book them on the Accrued Tax Account.
8. Now, when you pay the Tax via Bank Payment, you debit this Accrued Tax Account and your bank account is credited.
However, the system seems to get out of step as if you raise a journal entry against the tax accounts as it adds a tax transaction for the journal in the back end. If there is a journal, it is either a clearing entry as described above or it is to fix an error.
After my reconciliation, I think journal entries against the tax accounts should be exempted from reporting on the tax report or there is a flag provided to enable this. I should be able to do my final tax check after the balance is sitting in the Accrued tax Account and there is no balances in the tax accounts and this amount should agree with the tax report. Then I know I have done the complete job correctly.
If it is an error, (eg. may be I posted a sale as tax exempt when it was taxable and I am obligated to remit a portion of my sales), I would be manually recording details on the reports to demonstrate why the error needed to be corrected to support the journal entry. This scenario may mean there is a case to add an entry to the tax report if one side of the JE is against a sales account, but that may be a bit more complicated to implement.
If there is such a feature to enable excluding JE's from tax reports , please let me know as it would make life easier for me.
Rod